Smithtown Bagels

Welcome to Smithtown Bagels. Browse the menu, choose a section, and start your order.

Browse menu

Smithtown Bagels

Smithtown Bagels

Most Ordered

Dozen Bagels Choose 14 from over 20 flavors including classics like plain, sesame, and unique options like bacon, gluten-free. Mix and match for your perfect dozen bagels selection. $20.00
2 Eggs Meat and Cheese Bacon, Ham or Sausage $8.20
Bagel with Cream Cheese Choice of bagel topped with cream cheese. Options include plain, sesame, various egg varieties, fruit flavors, onion, garlic, salt, whole wheat, bacon, and gluten-free. $3.52
Bagel with Flavored Cream Cheese Fresh bagels with a variety of cream cheeses. Choices include plain, sesame, poppy, and more. Gluten-free option available. $4.36
1/2 Dozen Bagels Half dozen bagels with choices from classic to unique flavors: plain, sesame, poppy, cinnamon raisin, egg variants, pumpernickel, assorted grains, fruit-infused, onion, garlic, salt, whole wheat, bacon, and gluten-free options available. $10.00
2 Eggs with Bacon, Ham or Sausage Two eggs served with a choice of ham, bacon, sausage, or turkey bacon. $7.15
Hash Browns Golden, crispy shredded potatoes, lightly seasoned and pan-fried to a perfect texture. $4.75
Home Fries Diced potatoes, typically prepared with onions and peppers, pan-fried to achieve a golden crisp exterior. $4.75
2 eggs on a bagel Two eggs served atop a fresh bagel, combining simplicity with satisfaction for a classic breakfast choice. $6.40
8oz Temptee Cream Cheese Made with pasteurized milk cream, cheese culture, and salt, this 8oz tub of Temptee cream cheese is smoothly whipped for spreading. $6.99
Large coffee Large coffee with choice of flavor: Irish creme, chocolate, raspberry, dark roast, toasted almond, or French vanilla. Available in small, medium, or large servings. $3.45
8oz Philadelphia Cream Cheese Pasteurized milk cream, cheese culture, and salt, originating from Philadelphia, known for its creamy texture. $6.99

Paninis

Dieters Delight Panini Cracker peppermill turkey, lacy swiss cheese, and roasted peppers with honey mustard. $14.99
The Veggie Panini Grilled vegetables, fresh mozzarella, roaster peppers, and sun dried tomato with pesto sauce. $14.99
Brooklyn Paninis Hot pastrami, melted Swiss cheese, sauerkraut with spicy mustard. $14.99
The Godfather Panini Prosciutto, Genoa salami, picante provolone, roasted peppers with oil, and vinegar. $14.99
Grilled Chicken Panini Roasted peppers onions, and balsamic vinaigrette. $14.99
Long Islander Panini Boars Head black forest ham, Muenster cheese, and roasted peppers with mustard. $14.99
Chicken Supreme Panini Chicken cutlet, American cheese, bacon, red onions, and lettuce with mayo. $14.99
The Philly Panini Hot roast beef, and melted cheddar cheese with onions on a garlic pita. $14.99

Daily Lunch Specials

Cliff Hanger Daily Lunch Specials Chunky chicken salad, hot bacon, lettuce, and tomato. $11.99
Smithtown Classic Daily Lunch Special Hot chicken cutlet, bacon, lettuce tomato and American cheese. $13.49
Turkey Club Daily Lunch Special Roasted turkey, hot bacon, lettuce, and tomato. $11.99
ROUTE III Daily Lunch Special Cracked pepper, turkey, hot bacon, coleslaw, Swiss, and Russian dressing. $11.99
Classy Cutlet Daily Lunch Special Chicken cutlet, melted Swiss, hot bacon, lettuce, tomato and honey mustard. $14.99
Tuna Deluxe Daily Lunch Special Tuna, melted cheddar on croissant. $11.49
Woodsman Street Daily Lunch Special Hot turkey, melted mozzarella, and Russian dressing. $11.99
Triple Threat Daily Lunch Specials Roast beef, turkey, ham, mozzarella, Swiss and American cheese. $12.49
Smithtown Bull Daily Lunch Special Hot roast beef, bacon, and melted mozzarella. $12.49
Quick and Easy Daily Lunch Special Tuna with melted American. $11.99
Pizza Bagels Daily Lunch Special Choose any bagel. $6.49
Smithtown Daily Lunch Specials Grilled chicken, lettuce, tomato and honey mustard. $11.99
Italian Bomb Daily Lunch Special Bain, salami, roni, provolone, lettuce, tomato onions, and dressing. $11.99
Roller Coaster Daily Lunch Special Cracked pepper, turkey, roasted turkey, American cheese, lettuce, tomato, onions, coleslaw, and Russian dressing on a hero. $13.99
Marty Lyons Daily Lunch Special Roast beef, bacon, and cheddar cheese with brown gravy. $12.49
Smash Avocado Daily Lunch Special Topped with tomatoes and bacon. Serve with side salad and pickle. $11.99
Combo Daily Lunch Special Hot soup and buttered bagel. $6.99
Daily Double Daily Lunch Special Hot corned beef and pastrami on rye with hot mustard. $11.99
Kevin's Boars Head Daily Lunch Special Hot Corned beef, melted Swiss, sauerkraut, and Russian dressing. $11.99
Caleb Smith Daily Lunch Special Spicy Cajun beef, melted cheddar, lettuce, and tomato grilled onions. $12.99
Hot Stuff Daily Lunch Special Hot pastrami, and hot mustard. $11.99
Louisiana Meltdown Daily Lunch Special Cajun roast beef, and melted harvata. $11.49
Thunder Road Daily Lunch Special Spicy roast beef, melted cheddar, grilled onions, lettuce and tomato. $12.99
Fire on The Mountain Daily Lunch Special Cajun roast beef, cracked pepper turkey, melted harvata, grilled onions and hot sauce. $11.49
Main Street Daily Lunch Special Hot bacon, plain cream cheese, and sliced tomato. $10.99
Miller Place Daily Lunch Special Roast beef, melted swiss and coleslaw. $12.49
New Yorker Daily Lunch Special Hot pastrami, melted cheddar and coleslaw. $12.49
Wilbur's Special Daily Lunch Special Egg salad, bacon and tomato. $11.99
Grilled Cheese Daily Lunch Special Hot melted cheese with hot bacon, and tomato. $11.99
Gary's Bat Chaser Daily Lunch Special Cajun turkey, alpine Swiss, bacon and Russian dressing. $11.99

Premium Omelettes

Hungry Man Omelette Bacon,ham,sausage, potatoes,grilled onions and pepper jack cheese $14.34
Veggie Omelette Peppers, onions, roasted peppers, tomato, mushroom, avocado and cheddar cheese $14.34
5. Potato Omelette Sauteed onions, potatoes, bacon, and cheese. $14.34
3. Egg White Omelette Turkey, Alpine Swiss, and spinach. $13.34
4. Healthy Side Egg whites, spinach, mushroom and avocado. $13.34
Spicy Omelette Cajun Turkey, muenster cheese, jalapeno and onion $14.34
Greek Omelette Black olives, onion, tomato and feta cheese $14.34
I. Cheese Omelette $12.84
2. Western Omelette Ham, peppers and onions. $13.34

Pancakes

Pancake Platter A pancake platter typically includes a generous serving of pancakes accompanied by a variety of breakfast proteins and eggs, served with butter and syrup. $12.99
French Toast Classic French Toast with a hint of sweetness and a golden, fluffy texture. $10.99
French Toast Platter 2 eggs, bacon,ham or sausage. 2 pieces of french toast $13.59
Pancake Quesadilla Eggs, cheese, bacon and sausage between 2 pancakes $11.99
Silver Dollar Pancake Miniature buttermilk pancakes, often served as a delightful array of small, round treats. $5.99
Full Stack Pancake A full stack of pancakes typically includes five fluffy pancakes, often served with butter and a sprinkling of powdered sugar on top. $9.99

Cold Cuts per pound

Honey Turkey Sliced honey turkey, often paired with a hint of sweetness from honey, making it a popular choice for sandwiches or platters. $15.99
Roast Beef Sliced roast beef, typically prepared by roasting to enhance its natural flavors. $16.49
Bologna Bologna, typically served sliced, is a classic cold cut meat originating from finely ground pork, beef, or a mixture, seasoned with spices. $12.49
Salami Salami, typically paired with provolone, lettuce, tomato, and onions, offers a classic taste for cold cut enthusiasts. $12.99
Pastrami Smoked and cured beef, traditionally prepared and sliced for versatile use. $16.49
Corned Beef Tender slices of flavorful corned beef. $16.49
Cajun Turkey Seasoned with a blend of Cajun spices, this turkey is roasted to bring out a distinct, spicy flavor profile. $15.99
Crack Pepper Turkey Sliced crack pepper turkey, seasoned generously with cracked black pepper, offers a robust flavor ideal for enhancing any sandwich or platter. $15.99
American Cheese $10.99
Swiss Cheese $10.99
Alpine Swiss Cheese $12.49
Provolone Cheese $10.99
Mozzarella Cheese $10.99
Cheddar Cheese $10.99
Muenster Cheese $10.99
Pepper Jack Cheese $10.99
Ham Tender, savory sliced pork, perfectly cured and gently seasoned for a classic taste. $13.99
Turkey Sliced turkey, typically includes a variety of flavors such as oven-roasted, smoked, or honey maple. $13.99

Dairy

8oz Breakstone Butter Breakstone butter, 8oz, is a creamy and smooth butter, typically used for spreading on toast or for cooking and baking needs. $6.99
Half gallon milk A half gallon of milk, typically sourced to complement a variety of breakfast dishes and beverages. $4.99
Dozen eggs A dozen eggs, prepared to your liking, offering a versatile base for any breakfast dish. $5.99

Bagels

Bagel with Nova and Cream Cheese Nova and cream cheese atop your choice of bagel, including plain, sesame, multiple egg variations, pumpernickel, grain, fruity options, onion, garlic, salt, whole wheat, bacon, bialy, twists, dist, flagels, gluten-free. $10.39
Bagel with Butter Buttered bagel, choice of plain, sesame, poppy, and more, including strawberry, blueberry, and gluten-free options. $3.14
Bagel with Lite Flavored Cream Cheese Bagel selection paired with lite flavored cream cheese. Choose from plain, sesame, wide variety of egg, fruit, or grain options, and specialty choices like onion, garlic, bacon, and gluten-free options. $4.46
Lox Cream Cheese Assorted bagels with lox cream cheese. Choose from a variety including plain, sesame, grain varieties, fruit flavors, or special options like bacon, gluten-free. $5.05
Bagel w/Tofu Cream Cheese $4.36
Bagel with Lite Plain Cream Cheese Bagel topped with lite plain cream cheese. Choice of flavors: plain to exotic like bacon, strawberry, gluten free, and more. $3.63
Roll with butter Buttered bagel, choice of plain, sesame, and various infused flavors including cinnamon raisin, blueberry, garlic, or gluten-free options. $3.14
1 Bagel Choice of bagel flavors including sesame, poppy, cinnamon raisin, pumpernickel, various egg variations, berry, onion/garlic, and gluten-free options. $1.70

Breakfast Specials

Hungry Man Two eggs, ham, bacon, sausage, cheese. $11.99
The Works 3 eggs, Bacon, sausage, ham, cheese, sautéed onions home fries or hash browns on a hero $12.99
1 egg on a bagel A freshly cooked egg served atop a toasted bagel, offering a simple yet satisfying breakfast option. $6.00
Avocado Fresh and creamy fruit with a rich taste, perfect for adding a touch of luxury to any dish. $2.50
Sid of Turkey Bacon Sliced turkey bacon, typically prepared by grilling or frying to achieve a balance of crispiness and tenderness. $2.75
Pancake Quesadilla Sausage bacon eggs cheese and a hash brown sandwiched between 2 pancakes! $11.99
Small side of Ham, Bacon, or Sausage Choice of bacon, ham, or sausage as a side. $2.75

Drinks

Large flavored coffee Large coffee with a selection of flavors including Irish creme, chocolate, raspberry, dark roast, toasted almond, and French vanilla. Available in small, medium, large sizes. $3.55
Large tea A large serving of tea, available in various flavors including English breakfast, Earl Grey, chamomile, and green tea. $3.45
Med vanilla cappuccino Rich espresso blended with steamed milk and vanilla syrup, topped with a layer of frothy foam. $3.35
Small tea A small serving of tea, offering a variety of flavors including traditional and herbal options to suit your preference. $2.95
Med flavored coffee Med flavored coffee available in small, medium, large. Choose from Irish creme, chocolate, raspberry, dark roast, toasted almond, or french vanilla flavors. $3.35
Large Hot chocolate Steamed milk blended with rich chocolate, typically served large and can include whipped cream on top. $3.55
Small flavored coffee Small coffee with choice of irish creme, chocolate, raspberry, dark roast, toasted almond, or french vanilla flavor. $3.05
Small cappuccino A small cappuccino combines a double shot of espresso with steamed milk, typically finished with a layer of milk foam. $3.05
Small Hot chocolate Steamed milk blended with rich chocolate, typically served in a small size. $3.05
Med Hot chocolate Medium-sized, typically includes a blend of steamed milk and rich chocolate, often complemented with whipped cream. $3.35
Med tea Med tea is a carefully selected blend of tea leaves, typically enjoyed for its unique flavor profile. $3.45
Med cappuccino A med cappuccino combines espresso with a balanced amount of steamed milk and a generous layer of milk foam. $3.35
Large cappuccino A large cappuccino combines triple shots of espresso with steamed milk, typically crowned with a generous layer of milk foam. $3.55
Small vanilla cappuccino Espresso and steamed milk infused with vanilla, topped with a generous layer of milk foam. $3.05
Large vanilla cappuccino Espresso and steamed milk infused with vanilla flavor, topped with a generous amount of milk foam. $3.55
Small Coffee Small serving of coffee. Available in medium and large sizes. $2.95
Med coffee Medium coffee available in small, medium, large sizes. Choose from flavors: Irish creme, chocolate, raspberry, dark roast, toasted almond, French vanilla. $3.25
Small simply orange 100% pure squeezed pasteurized orange juice. A delicious orange juice with a taste that’s the next best thing to fresh squeezed. $3.25
Half Gallon Tropicana Half gallon of Tropicana juice, typically includes a variety of flavors such as orange, apple, and cranberry. $7.99
Chocolate Nesquick Nesquick chocolate drink typically includes milk and Nesquick chocolate powder, offering a sweet and satisfying beverage option for breakfast. $3.25
Peach snapple All-natural peach-flavored tea, combining fruit notes with traditional black tea. $3.25
Quart Fruit Punch Gatorade A crisp, satisfying taste to quench thirst and energize without caffeine $4.50
Dr. Pepper Unique blend of 23 flavors, carbonated soft drink. $3.25
Arizona Arnold Palmer A refreshing blend of iced tea and lemonade, inspired by the classic beverage. $3.25
Cool Blue Gatorade A crisp, satisfying taste to quench thirst and energize without caffeine $3.25
Monster A power-packed energy drink to keep you energized and focused. $5.00
Quart Cool Blue Gatorade A crisp, satisfying taste to quench thirst and energize without caffeine $4.50
Red Vitamin Water Vitamin and nutrient-enhanced water beverage with electrolytes and other good stuff. $3.25
Lemon Snapple Snapple with a refreshing lemon flavor, served in a bottle. $3.25
15oz apple juice Pressed from select apples, this 15oz apple juice offers a naturally sweet and refreshing taste. $3.25
Red Bull Invigorating Energy Surge: The Classic Red Bull Experience $5.00
Coke Zero The same great taste but with zero calories. $3.25
Apple Snapple A refreshing juice drink blending the crisp, sweet flavor of apples, served chilled. $3.25
Orange Gatorade A crisp, satisfying taste to quench thirst and energize without caffeine $3.25
Pint orange juice A generous serving of freshly squeezed orange juice, offering a natural and refreshing taste with every sip. May contain pulp. $3.25
YooHoo Classic chocolate drink perfect for chocolate lovers; rich, velvety and satisfyingly sweet. $3.25
Quart Diet Lemon Snapple A quart-sized bottle of Snapple tea, lightly sweetened with a refreshing lemon flavor, offered in a diet version. $4.50
1 1/2 Liter Poland Spring A larger bottle of Poland Spring, offering a refreshing and pure spring water experience. $4.00
Sprite The cold, refreshing flavors of lemon and lime, perfectly blended. $3.25
Arizona Peach Fresh brewed tea infused with the sweet essence of peach. $3.25
Pepsi The bold, refreshing, robust cola $3.25
Mountain Dew Exhilarate and quench your thirst with a one of a kind taste. $3.25
Yellow Vitamin Water Vitamin and nutrient-enhanced water beverage with electrolytes and other good stuff. $3.25
Stewart's Orange Cream Soda Stewart's orange cream soda combines the classic taste of orange soda with a smooth cream flavor, reminiscent of a traditional cream soda experience. $3.25
Stewart's Cream Soda A classic cream soda offering a smooth vanilla cream taste. $3.25
Stewart's Black Cherry Soda A carbonated drink infused with the essence of black cherries for a sweet and tart flavor profile. $3.25
Arizona Lemon Iced tea infused with a distinct lemon flavor. $3.25
Raspberry Snapple A bottled tea drink infused with the natural flavor of raspberries. $3.25
Half and Half Snapple Half and half Snapple combines the refreshing taste of iced tea with tangy lemonade, offering a balanced and thirst-quenching beverage. $3.25
Kiwi Strawberry Snapple A juice drink blending the tastes of kiwi and strawberry. $3.25
Diet Lemon Snapple A refreshing tea beverage, lightly sweetened and flavored with lemon, offering a diet-friendly option. $3.25
Diet Peach Snapple Diet peach Snapple is a low-calorie peach-flavored tea beverage. $3.25
Quart Lemon Snapple A quart-sized Snapple tea flavored with lemon, offering a refreshing and slightly tangy taste. $4.50
Lemon Gatorade A crisp, satisfying taste to quench thirst and energize without caffeine $3.25
Fruit Punch Gatorade A crisp, satisfying taste to quench thirst and energize without caffeine $3.25
Quart Lemon Gatorade A crisp, satisfying taste to quench thirst and energize without caffeine $4.50
Quart Orange Gatorade A crisp, satisfying taste to quench thirst and energize without caffeine $4.50
20 oz. Poland Spring 20 oz. Poland Spring water is a refreshing bottled spring water, providing hydration. $3.00
1 Liter Poland Spring A 1-liter bottle of Poland Spring, offering a refreshing and pure natural spring water for hydration. $3.50
15oz cranberry juice Cranberry juice, served in a 15oz portion, typically includes pure cranberry juice without additional sweeteners or flavors. $3.25
15oz orange juice Freshly squeezed orange juice, typically containing pulp from ripe oranges. $3.25
15oz pineapple orange A refreshing blend of pineapple and orange juices, typically served as a revitalizing drink. $3.25
Strawberry Nesqick Strawberry Nesquik: A sweet beverage made with milk and strawberry-flavored Nesquik powder, offering a delightful blend of creamy and fruity flavors. $3.25
Vanilla Nesquick Typically includes vanilla-flavored milk mixed with Nesquick powder for a sweet, smooth drink. $3.25
Cookie Dough Nesquick A rich milkshake blended with Nesquik chocolate and fudge brownie pieces. $3.25
Diet Pepsi A crisp tasting, refreshing pop of sweet, fizzy bubbles without calories. $3.25
7 Up Effervescent lemon-lime soda, a refreshing thirst quencher. $3.25
Orange Soda Effervescent Orange Soda: A Sweet, Citrus-Infused Beverage $3.25
Grape Soda Effervescent, refreshingly sweet grape-flavored carbonated drink. $3.25
Orange Vitamin Water Vitamin and nutrient-enhanced water beverage with electrolytes and other good stuff. $3.25
Black Vitamin Water Vitamin and nutrient-enhanced water beverage with electrolytes and other good stuff. $3.25
Stewart's Root Beer Stewart's root beer is a classic, carbonated beverage traditionally crafted with a blend of natural root beer extract, sweetened with cane sugar. $3.25
Diet Raspberry Snapple A tea-based beverage infused with the essence of raspberries, offering a lighter choice without added sugar. $3.25
Orangeade Snapple A refreshing bottled drink blending the tangy flavor of oranges with the unique taste profile of Snapple. $3.25
Fruit Punch Snapple A refreshing blend of fruit flavors, this Snapple Fruit Punch is a bottled beverage offering a sweet and tangy taste experience. $3.25
Mango Madness Snapple Snapple Mango Madness is a bottled beverage offering a vibrant blend of mango flavors. $3.25
Quart Peach Snapple A quart-sized bottle of Snapple featuring a refreshing peach-flavored tea blend. $4.50
Quart Diet Peach Snapple A quart-sized bottle of Snapple, offering a diet peach tea that typically includes a blend of peach flavor and tea. $4.50
Grape Gatorade A crisp, satisfying taste to quench thirst and energize without caffeine $3.25
Glacier Freeze Gatorade A crisp, satisfying taste to quench thirst and energize without caffeine $3.25
16 oz. Poland Spring 16 oz. bottle of Poland Spring, offering a refreshing serving of natural spring water. $2.75
Pineapple mango Freshly blended pineapple and mango juice, offering a naturally sweet and tropical flavor. $3.25
15oz grape juice Pure grape juice, typically includes a natural blend of grapes without added sweeteners. $3.25
Raspberry Peach Raspberry peach drink typically features real raspberries and peach puree, blended with a refreshing base for a balanced fruity flavor. $3.25
Strawberry Banana Nesquick Strawberry Banana Nesquick Smoothie: Blended strawberries, banana, and Nesquick powder, typically mixed with yogurt and milk for a creamy and fruity breakfast drink. $3.25
Cream O'Land Chocolate Milk $3.25
Diet Coke A crisp, refreshing taste you know and love with zero calories. $3.25
Coke The cold, refreshing, sparkling classic that America loves. $3.25

Salads by the pound

Egg Salad A blend of chopped hard-boiled eggs and mayonnaise, seasoned to taste. $13.50
Crab Meat Salad Crab meat salad typically includes fresh crab meat mixed with diced celery, onions, and a creamy dressing, often garnished with fresh herbs. $13.50
Macaroni salad Homemade creamy pasta salad tossed with fresh vegetables $9.50
Veggie Tuna Tuna mixed with carrots, onions, and green peppers, combined in a light dressing. $16.50
Potato salad Creamy potato salad with fresh herbs and a tangy mustard dressing. $9.50
Coleslaw Crisp shredded cabbage in a creamy, tangy dressing. $9.50
Cucumber salad Crisp cucumber slices tossed in a light, refreshing vinaigrette. $9.50
Pasta salad Zesty medley of pasta and fresh vegetables make this satisfying pasta salad. $9.50
Lite Tuna Lite tuna salad typically includes tuna mixed with low-fat mayonnaise and a variety of chopped vegetables. $16.50
Cran apple coleslaw Shredded cabbage and carrots mixed with diced cranberries and apples, typically dressed with mayonnaise. $10.00
Egg white spinach salad Egg white spinach salad combines fresh spinach and egg whites, typically accented with ingredients like tomatoes and onions, dressed lightly to complement the flavors. $15.00
Chicken Salad Shredded chicken mixed with creamy dressing, celery, and seasonings. $15.50
Tuna Albacore tuna mixed with diced celery, red onions, and mayonnaise, typically prepared by the pound. $15.50
Smithtown Bagels8.6(24)
Reviews 8.6 · 24
  • MMaya 9.3

    Sample review: came out hot and the flavors were balanced — would come back.

  • JJordan 8.8

    Sample review: cozy room, easy pacing, and a menu that is fun to browse.

  • PPriya 8.0

    Sample review: generous portions and the kitchen nailed the seasoning.

  • LLeo 9.1

    Sample review: great for sharing a few plates without it feeling fussy.

  • SSofia 7.8

    Sample review: service checked in at the right moments, nothing rushed.

  • AAndre 9.2

    Sample review: clean presentation and everything arrived together.