Bagels on Main

Welcome to Bagels on Main. Browse the menu, choose a section, and start your order.

Browse menu

Bagels on Main

Bagels on Main

Most Ordered

Cream Cheese Assorted bagels: plain, whole wheat, everything, sesame, cinnamon raisin, and more. Choice of cream cheese spread. Options include blueberry, garlic, onion, and sunflower. $4.99
2 Eggs on a Bagel Soft bagel filled with two eggs $5.99
Vegetable Cream Cheese Vegetable cream cheese spread on a choice of bagels or rolls, including plain, everything, sesame, garlic, and more. Available by the lb. Options like whole wheat to blueberry. $5.69
Cold Brewed Iced Coffee Cold brewed iced coffee, choice of sizes: large (32 oz.), medium (24 oz.), small (16 oz.). $4.00
Smoked Atlantic Nova Salmon (Bagel) Ripe Tomato Slices, Bermuda Onion, Plain or Lite Cream Cheese and a Crisp Pickle Wedge Garni and Side Salad. $13.50
Assorted Freshly Baked Freshly baked muffins. Choose from blueberry, crumb varieties, chocolate chip, cinnamon, corn, raisin bran, or pistachio. $4.25
Butter Butter-schmeared bagel, available in assorted varieties including plain, sesame, everything, multigrain, and more exotic choices like French toast and rainbow. $3.99
Iced Coffee Chilled coffee served in three sizes: small (16 oz.), medium (24 oz.), large (32 oz.). $3.00
Bacon Egg & Cheese Classic New York Bacon Egg & Cheese $9.29
Scallion Cream Cheese Scallion cream cheese spread over choice of bagels including plain, multigrain options, whole wheat varieties, and specialty flavors like french toast and blueberry. $5.69
The Hungry Man Platter Three eggs any style, bacon, sausage ham, cheese, home fries, and a buttered bagel. $13.99
Columbian Coffee Columbian coffee, choice of 12 oz., 16 oz., or 20 oz. sizes. $2.99

Beverages

Tropicana Orange Juice Tropicana Orange Juice: 100% pure and natural orange juice. $3.49
Chocolate Nesquick Enjoy a classic blend of milk and Nesquick chocolate powder, offering a sweet and satisfying beverage to complement your breakfast. $3.49
Arizona Iced Tea Typically includes lemon, green tea, or a half and half blend. $3.49
Yoohoo Enjoy the classic chocolate-flavored drink, typically creamy and refreshing, with a nostalgic taste. $3.49
Redbull 8.4oz A lightly carbonated energy drink with caffeine, taurine, B vitamins, sugar, and water. $3.49
Snapple Lemon $3.49
Snapple Half & Half $3.49
Snapple Lemon Zero Sugar $3.49
Snapple Peach $3.49
Snapple Kiwi Strawberry $3.49
Snapple Peach Zero Sugar $3.49
Diet Coke A crisp, refreshing taste you know and love with zero calories. $3.49
Coke The cold, refreshing, sparkling classic that America loves. $3.49

Sandwich Maker

Classic Tuna Salad Tuna salad on choice of bagel, bialy, or roll; option to order by the lb. Side choices include a variety of salads: broccoli, macaroni, tomato, pasta, bean, and more. $12.50
Chicken Cutlet Fresh Chicken Cutlet made fresh daily. $13.99
Bacon, Lettuce, Tomato (BLT) Crispy bacon, fresh lettuce, tomato on choice of bagel, bialy, or roll. Served with a variety of salads: broccoli, macaroni, cole slaw, cucumber & tomato, greek pasta, and more. $12.99
Classic Egg Salad Egg salad with a choice of bagel, bialy, roll, or by the pound. Select sides from a variety of salads including pasta, potato, and greens. $10.50
Lite Veggie Chicken Salad Lite veggie chicken salad on choice of bagel, bialy, or roll, or by the lb. Choose from a variety of sides including salads with pasta, beans, or vegetables. $11.99
Chicken Waldorf Chicken Waldorf Sandwich: Choose from bagel, bialy, by the lb., or roll. Side options include salads like Greek pasta, Israeli, Tuscany bean, and more. $13.50
Breaded Chicken Cutlet Breaded chicken cutlet on choice of bagel, bialy, or roll. Option by the lb. available. Sides: salads including pasta, potato, bean, Greek, or health varieties. $11.99
Spring Time Tuna with Apples & Cranberries Tuna mixed with apples and cranberries, select size: bagel, bialy, by the lb., roll. Includes choice of 13 salads, ranging from classic to Mediterranean twists. $11.99
Honey Mustard Tuna Salad Honey mustard tuna salad on your choice of bagel, bialy, by the lb., or roll. Select from a variety of sides including salads and pasta. $11.99
Lite Veggie Tuna Salad Choice of bagel, bialy, roll, or by the lb. Accompanied by a range of sides including salads with broccoli, macaroni, cucumber, pasta, beans, and more. $11.99
Whitefish Salad Whitefish salad on your choice of bagel, bialy, or roll. Served with a side from options including various salads like Greek pasta, Israeli, or health salad. $12.50
Baked Salmon Salad Baked salmon flaked over your choice of bagel, bialy, roll, or by the lb. Paired with a variety of sides including salads and pasta. $12.50
Egg, Onion & Mushroom Salad Egg salad featuring onions and mushrooms. Offered on a bagel, bialy, roll, or by the lb. Choose from a variety of sides, including salads and pasta options. $10.50
Spinach Egg White Salad Spinach egg white on choice of bagel, bialy, or roll. Served with a selection of salads including pasta, bean, and cucumber options. $11.50
Chicken Salad Chicken salad available on bagel, bialy, roll, or by the lb. Choose from a variety of sides including various salads like Greek pasta, Israeli, or Tuscany bean. $12.50
Honey Mustard Chicken Honey mustard chicken nestled between your choice of bagel, bialy, roll, or by the lb. Comes with an option of 13 diverse salads, from Greek pasta to Tuscany bean. $12.99

Signature Sandwiches

California Wrap Hot grilled chicken, avocado, bacon, chipotle mayo, lettuce & tomato in a whole wheat wrap. $14.99
Chicken Caeser Salad Wrap Grilled all‑white‑meat chicken breast, crisp romaine lettuce, and shaved Parmesan tossed in our house‑made, zesty Caesar dressing, wrapped snugly in a soft flour tortilla. Finished with a sprinkling of crunchy garlic‑herb crouton crumbs for that classic Caesar bite—portable, satisfying, and perfect for lunch on the go. $14.99
Sweet Sandy Honey maple turkey, alpine lace cheese, lettuce, tomato, honey mustard. $13.99
Big Bird Breaded chicken cutlet, melted American, lettuce, tomato, and Russian dressing. $13.99
General Lee Cracked pepper turkey, Pepper Jack cheese, bacon, lettuce, tomato, mayo. $13.99
Bonaccorso's Italiano Salami, ham cappy, pepperoni, Provolone lettuce, tomato onion, oil and vinegar. $14.99
Main St. Monti Cristo Grilled ham, turkey, Swiss, coleslaw on our egg battered challah bread and Russian dressing. $13.99
Reuben Reuben pastrami, corned beef, Swiss your choice of cole slaw or kraut on our grilled rye with Russian dressing. $15.99
Jon's 6 Pack Chicken cutlet melted Mozzarella smothered in our homemade buffalo sauce. $13.99
G.I. Joe (American) Ham, turkey, roast beef American cheese lettuce, tomato, mayo. $13.99
The Commack Bomb Chicken cutlet, melted Cheddar, bacon, bbq sauce. $13.99
Gabby's Fave Turkey, Swiss cole slaw, russian dressing on our grilled whole wheat bread. $13.99
Big Dan Blackened turkey melted Mozzarella. $13.99
Christine's Combo Grilled chicken, roasted peppers, alpine lace. Lettuce. Tomato, honey mustard. $13.99
Rolf's Royale Roast beef melted Mozzarella. $15.99

Bagels

Dozen of any bagels Dozen of any bagels $23.00
Everything Everything bagel available as single or by the dozen. $1.95
Our Famous Rainbow Bagel (Each) Our famous rainbow bagel is a vibrant, multicolored bagel, typically enjoyed with a variety of spreads or toppings to complement its visually appealing presentation. $2.45
Mini Bagels Mini bagels available individually or by the dozen. $1.45
Egg Everything Egg everything bagel, available individually or by the dozen. $1.95
Flagel A flat bagel, hand-rolled and kettle-boiled before being baked to achieve a unique texture. Available in varieties such as plain, sesame, and everything. $2.75
Plain Plain bagel, available individually or by the dozen. $1.95
Garlic Garlic bagel, available as a single or by the dozen. $1.95
Egg Egg sandwich on a toasted bagel, options for single or dozen eggs. $1.95
Cinnamon Raisin Cinnamon raisin bagel, available individually or by the dozen. $1.95
Blueberry Blueberry bagel, available single or in a dozen. $1.95
Onion Onion bagel, available singly or by the dozen. $1.95
Poppy Poppy bagel, available individually or in dozens. $1.95
Salt Salt bagel available individually or by the dozen. $1.95
Bialys Bialys bagel: available in single or dozen. Light, chewy texture with a filled center. $1.95
Honey Whole Wheat Honey whole wheat bagel, available singly or by the dozen. $1.95
Marble Marble bagel, available individually or by the dozen. $1.95
Sesame Sesame bagel, available as single or by the dozen. $1.95
Pumpernickel Pumpernickel bagel available individually or by the dozen. $1.95

Delicious Duos

Sandwich & Cookie Sandwich options include Big Willie, Bonaccorso's Italiano, The Commack Bomb. Paired with a choice of Black & White, Chocolate Chip, or Oatmeal Raisin cookies. $16.94
Sandwich & Salad Big Willie sandwich paired with a choice of Classic Egg Salad, Honey Mustard Tuna Salad, or Smoked Atlantic Nova Salmon on a bagel. $24.49

Flagels

Plain Soft, chewy plain flagel with a slightly crisp exterior. $2.70
Sesame Topped with sesame seeds, this flagel offers a chewy, dense texture with a hint of nuttiness. $2.70
Whole Wheat A flat bagel made with whole wheat flour, offering a denser, chewier texture than traditional bagels. $2.70
Poppy Topped with crunchy poppy seeds, these flagels offer a delightful twist on traditional bagels. $2.70
Everything An everything flagel, typically includes a topping of sesame seeds, poppy seeds, onion, and garlic flakes, freshly baked. $2.70
Sunflower A flagel generously topped with sunflower seeds, offering a unique twist to the traditional breakfast bread. $2.70

Assorted Fresh Baked Goods

Cinnamon Rolls Deliciously soft, freshly baked rolls, topped off with rich cinnamon $3.99
Apple Turnovers Puff pastry filled with a blend of sweet apples and a hint of cinnamon, baked until golden. $3.99
Brownies Perfect for the sweet tooth in you $3.99
Chocolate Cigar Wrapped in a delicate pastry, this treat combines premium chocolate, offering a simple yet satisfying experience. $3.99
Black & White Cookies Soft, cake-like cookies with one side coated in vanilla icing and the other in chocolate, blending two classic flavors. $3.99
Cheese Danish Delicate, Flaky Pastry Filled with Rich, Creamy Cheese $3.99
Linzer Tarts A delightful tart made with a nutty dough, typically filled with a sweet raspberry jam and dusted with powdered sugar. $3.99
Homemade Old Fashioned - Assorted Rugalach Per pound. $18.99
Croissant Flaky, Butter-rich French Pastry with a Golden, Crisp Exterior $3.99
Crumb Cake Moist, buttery cake with a delightfully crunchy streusel topping. $3.99

Hot Off the Grill

Buttermilk Pancakes Three buttermilk pancakes, typically served with butter and maple syrup. $9.49
2 Eggs with Cheese Specify cheese and type of bread. $6.59
Brian Special Classic Bacon Egg & Cheese, with a hash brown and grape jelly. Comes on a toasted & scooped everything bagel. $10.99
2 Eggs with Meat Specify meat and type of bread. $7.49
Western Omelette Three eggs, diced ham peppers, onions, home fries, and a buttered bagel. $11.99
Challah French Toast Thick slices of challah bread, typically soaked in a vanilla and cinnamon-infused custard, grilled until golden brown, and often dusted with powdered sugar. $9.49
Greek Omelette Three eggs, Feta cheese, caramelized onions, home fries, and a buttered bagel. $10.99

Bagels with a Schmear

1lb Plain Cream Cheese $14.99
Plain Tofutti Bagel with smooth, dairy-free tofutti. Choose from an array of options like sesame, poppy, everything, multigrain, and more. Available in styles including plain, bialy, and flagel. $6.49
1lb Veggie Cream Cheese $15.99
Strawberry Cream Cheese Strawberry cream cheese spread across a choice of bagels: plain, sesame, everything, garlic, multigrain, more. Option for by the lb. Flavorful breakfast selection. $5.69
Sundried Tomato Cream Cheese Sundried tomato cream cheese with versatile bread options including plain, bialy, and roll; flavors range from sesame to blueberry and egg everything; available by the lb. $5.69
Nova Spread Cream Cheese Nova spread cream cheese available on a variety of bases: plain, sesame, poppy seed, everything, and more. Choose from roll, bialy, flagel, or by the pound. Options include egg, whole wheat, pumpernickel, cinnamon raisin, french toast, and blueberry. $6.95
1lb Scallion Cream Cheese $15.99
1lb Lox Cream Cheese $23.99
Walnut Raisin Cream Cheese Walnut Raisin Cream Cheese spread. Choice of bagel from plain, sesame, everything, multigrain, egg, garlic, or cinnamon raisin, among others. $5.69
Veggie Tofutti Veggie Tofutti spread on choice of bagel: plain to sunflower, including options like everything, rye, whole wheat. Multigrain and specialty flavors available. $6.94

Panini Palace

Madison Avenue Grilled chicken, Mozzarella, roasted peppers, pesto. $13.99
Bees Nest Honey ham, honey turkey, alpine lace, cole slaw, Russian dressing. $13.99
Bubbalicious Breaded chicken cutlet, Cheddar, bacon, bbq sauce. $13.99
Andy's Delight Roast beef, bacon, Cheddar hot sauce, bbq sauce. $13.99
Big Willie Honey turkey, alpine lace, bacon, lettuce, tomato, honey mustard. $13.99
Glen Head Cracked pepper turkey, roasted peppers, Cheddar, onions, mayo. $13.99

Smoked Fish & Appetizing

Smoked Atlantic Belly Lox (Bagel) Crisp Lettuce, Ripe Tomato Slices, Bermuda Onion, Plain or Lite Cream Cheese and a Crisp Pickle Wedge Garni and Side Salad. $13.50
Baked Kippered Salmon Salad (Bialy) Crisp Lettuce, Ripe Tomato Slices, Bermuda Onion, Plain or Lite Cream Cheese and a Crisp Pickle Wedge Garni and Side Salad. $11.50
Premium Whitefish Salad (Bagel) Crisp Lettuce, Ripe Tomato Slices, Bermuda Onion, Plain or Lite Cream Cheese and a Crisp Pickle Wedge Garni and Side Salad. $11.50
Premium Whitefish Salad (By the Lb.) Crisp Lettuce, Ripe Tomato Slices, Bermuda Onion, Plain or Lite Cream Cheese and a Crisp Pickle Wedge Garni and Side Salad. $28.00
Smoked Atlantic Belly Lox (By the Lb.) Crisp Lettuce, Ripe Tomato Slices, Bermuda Onion, Plain or Lite Cream Cheese and a Crisp Pickle Wedge Garni and Side Salad. $62.00
Smoked Sable Plate (Bagel) Crisp Lettuce, Ripe Tomato Slices, Bermuda Onion, Plain or Lite Cream Cheese and a Crisp Pickle Wedge Garni and Side Salad. $10.00
Smoked Sable Plate (Bialy) Crisp Lettuce, Ripe Tomato Slices, Bermuda Onion, Plain or Lite Cream Cheese and a Crisp Pickle Wedge Garni and Side Salad. $10.00
Smoked Sable Plate (Roll) Crisp Lettuce, Ripe Tomato Slices, Bermuda Onion, Plain or Lite Cream Cheese and a Crisp Pickle Wedge Garni and Side Salad. $10.00
Smoked Sable Plate (By the Lb.) Crisp Lettuce, Ripe Tomato Slices, Bermuda Onion, Plain or Lite Cream Cheese and a Crisp Pickle Wedge Garni and Side Salad. $48.00
Premium Whitefish Salad (Bialy) Crisp Lettuce, Ripe Tomato Slices, Bermuda Onion, Plain or Lite Cream Cheese and a Crisp Pickle Wedge Garni and Side Salad. $11.50
Premium Whitefish Salad (Roll) Crisp Lettuce, Ripe Tomato Slices, Bermuda Onion, Plain or Lite Cream Cheese and a Crisp Pickle Wedge Garni and Side Salad. $11.50
Smoked Atlantic Nova Salmon (By the Lb.) Crisp Lettuce, Ripe Tomato Slices, Bermuda Onion, Plain or Lite Cream Cheese and a Crisp Pickle Wedge Garni and Side Salad. $62.00
Baked Kippered Salmon (By the Lb.) Crisp Lettuce, Ripe Tomato Slices, Bermuda Onion, Plain or Lite Cream Cheese and a Crisp Pickle Wedge Garni and Side Salad. $45.00

Specialty Side Salads

Chicken Salad Freshly tossed greens with seasoned chicken, and crisp veggies $18.00
Greek Pasta Salad Per pound. $11.99
Old Fashioned Cucumber Salad Per pound. $11.99
Pasta Primavera Per pound. $11.99
Sun Dried Tomato Pasta Per pound. $11.99
Cucumber, Tomato & Onion Salad Per pound. $11.99
Three Bean Salad Per pound. $11.99
California Broccoli Salad Per pound. $11.99
Red Bliss Potato Salad Per pound. $9.99
Classic Macaroni Salad Per pound. $9.99
Israeli Salad Per pound. $11.99
Cucumber & Tomato Salad Per pound. $11.99
Health Salad Per pound. $11.99
Cole Slaw Per pound. $9.99

Chopped Salads

Chopped Salads Any six items. $9.99

The Salad Maker

Greek Two eggs feta, caramelized onions, and home fries. $10.99
Chefs Salad Mixed greens topped with slices of ham, turkey, swiss cheese, and hard-boiled egg, accompanied by tomatoes and cucumbers. $14.99
House Salad Crisp romaine lettuce covered with grilled chicken, goat cheese, mandarin orange, craisins, and walnuts. $9.99
Classic Caesar Crisp romaine lettuce, crunchy croutons, and grated Parmesan cheese, all tossed in a creamy Caesar dressing. $10.99
Tossed Garden Mixed greens, tomatoes, cucumbers, and carrots, typically dressed with a light vinaigrette. $10.99

Boars Head Signature Sandwiches

Ham Ham sandwich served with a choice of salad: from classic macaroni to tuscany bean salad, including cucumber & tomato and Greek pasta options. $11.99
Roast Beef Roast beef sandwich served with choice of side: ranging from various salads like California broccoli, Greek pasta, to red bliss potato and Tuscany bean. $13.99
Turkey Turkey sandwich with a choice of sides, including salads like California broccoli, classic macaroni, Greek pasta, health, Israeli, and more, or sun-dried tomato pasta. $11.99
Salami Boars Head salami sandwich with choice of side: variety of salads including pasta, potato, vegetable, and bean options. $8.99
Cheese Cheese sandwich featuring Boar's Head signature selections. Served with a choice of side: salads ranging from broccoli to Greek pasta, bean, and various potato salads. $6.99
Brisket Brisket sandwich with a choice of side including a variety of salads: broccoli, macaroni, cucumber & tomato, Greek pasta, and more. $9.99
Corned Beef Boars Head corned beef paired with a choice of salads: from classic macaroni to Israeli and Tuscany bean. $10.99
Pastrami Pastrami sandwich, choice of side: variety of salads including broccoli, macaroni, Greek pasta, health, Israeli, cucumber, tomato, red potato, and bean options. $10.99

Coffee Bar

Arnold Palmer Half Sweet Tea and Half Lemonade $3.78
Deli Iced Tea (Sweetened) Sweetened iced tea. Choose from 16 oz., 24 oz., or 32 oz. sizes. $3.78
French Vanilla Iced Coffee French vanilla flavor. Sizes: 16 oz., 24 oz., 32 oz. $3.78
Hot Chocolate Rich, creamy hot chocolate. Three sizes: large 20 oz., medium 16 oz., small 12 oz. $2.00
Hot Tea Hot tea in three sizes: 32 oz. large, 24 oz. medium, 16 oz. small. $3.00
Deli Lemonade Available sizes - Large (32 Oz.), Medium (24 Oz.), Small (16 Oz.). $3.78
Gourmet Coffee Gourmet coffee, choose size: large (20 oz.), medium (16 oz.), small (12 oz.). $2.99
Bagels on Main8.6(24)
Reviews 8.6 · 24
  • MMaya 9.3

    Sample review: came out hot and the flavors were balanced — would come back.

  • JJordan 8.8

    Sample review: cozy room, easy pacing, and a menu that is fun to browse.

  • PPriya 8.0

    Sample review: generous portions and the kitchen nailed the seasoning.

  • LLeo 9.1

    Sample review: great for sharing a few plates without it feeling fussy.

  • SSofia 7.8

    Sample review: service checked in at the right moments, nothing rushed.

  • AAndre 9.2

    Sample review: clean presentation and everything arrived together.